| 
			  
			
			
  
			
			 
			from
			
			MindControlForum Website
 
				
					
						| 
						
						DISCLAIMER 
						
						 
						. 
						The following is a staff memorandum or other working 
			document prepared for the members of the Advisory Committee on Human 
			Radiation Experiments. It should not be construed as representing 
			the final conclusions of fact or interpretation of the issues. All 
			staff memoranda are subject to revision based on further information 
			and analysis. For conclusions and recommendations of the Advisory 
			Committee, readers are advised to consult the Final Report to be 
			published in 1995. |  
				
				  
				MEMORANDUM 
 TO: Members of the Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments
 
 FROM: Advisory Committee Staff
 
 DATE: April 5, 1995
 
 RE: Post-World War II Recruitment of German Scientists - Project 
			Paperclip
 
 The Air Force’s School of Aviation Medicine (SAM) at 
				Brooks Air 
			Force Base in Texas conducted dozens of human radiation experiments 
			during the Cold War, among them flash-blindness studies in connection 
			with atomic weapons tests, and data-gathering for total-body 
			irradiation studies conducted in Houston. (These have been the 
			subject of prior briefing books.) Because of the extensive postwar 
				recruiting of German scientists for the SAM and other U.S. defense 
			installations, and in light of the central importance of the 
			Nuremberg prosecutions to the Advisory Committee’s work, members of 
			the staff have collected documentary evidence about Project 
			Paperclip from the National Archives and Department of Defense 
			records. (The departments of Justice and Defense, as well as the 
			Archives staff, have provided substantial assistance in this 
			effort.)
 
 The experiments for which Nazi investigators were tried included 
			many related to aviation research. These were mainly high-altitude 
			exposure studies, oxygen deprivation experiments, and cold studies 
			related to air-sea rescue operations. This information about air 
			crew hazards was important to both sides, and, of course, continued 
			to be important to military organizations in the Cold War.
 
 
				Background of Project Paperclip
 
 Project Paperclip was a postwar and Cold War operation carried out 
			by the Joint Intelligence Objectives Agency (JIOA).1 [Operation 
			Paperclip’s code name was said to have originated because scientific 
			recruits’ papers were paperclipped with regular immigration forms. 
			The JIOA was a special intelligence office reporting to the Director 
			of Intelligence in the War Department, comparable to the 
			intelligence chief of today’s Joint Chiefs of Staff.] Paperclip
				had 
			two aims:
 
					
						
					 
				At least 
			1,600 scientists and their dependents were recruited and brought to 
			the United States by Paperclip and its successor projects through 
			the early 1970s. The most famous of these was Wernher von Braun.
				
 
				1   
				In recent years, it has been alleged that many of these individuals 
			were brought to the United States in violation of American 
			government policy not to permit the entrance of "ardent Nazis" into 
			the country, that many were security risks, and that at least some 
			were implicated in Holocaust-related activities. 
 The secondary literature on 
				Paperclip includes Linda Hunt, 
				
				Secret 
			Agenda (1991) and Tom Bowers, 
				
				The Paperclip Conspiracy (1989). The 
			following is drawn from these sources and material retrieved from 
			the National Archives and DOD files.
 
 
				Nuremberg and Postwar Recruitment of Scientists
 
 At the time of its inception, 
				Paperclip was a matter of controversy 
			in the War Department, as demonstrated by a November 27,1946 
			memorandum from General Groves, director of the Manhattan Project, 
			relating to the bringing to the United States of the eminent 
			physicist Otto Hahn.
 
 Groves wrote that the 
				Manhattan Project
			does not desire to utilize the services of foreign scientists in the 
			United States, either directly with the Project or with any 
			affiliated organization. This has consistently been my views. (sic) 
			I should like to make it clear, however, that I see no objection to 
			bringing to the United States such carefully screened physicists as 
			would contribute materially to the welfare of the United States and 
			would remain permanently in the United States as naturalized 
			citizens. I strongly recommend against foreign physicists coming in 
			contact with our atomic energy program in any way. If they are 
			allowed to see or discuss the work of the Project the security of 
			our information would get out of control. (Attachment 1)
   
				Biomedical Scientists at American Facilities
 
 A number of military research sites recruited Paperclip scientists 
			with backgrounds in aeromedicine, radiobiology and ophthalmology. 
			These institutions included the SAM, where radiation experiments 
			were conducted, and other military sites, particularly the Edgewood 
			Arsenal of the Army’s Chemical Corps.
 
 
				2 
				The portfolio of experiments at the 
				SAM was one that would 
			particularly benefit from the Paperclip recruits. Experiments there 
			included total-body irradiation, space medicine and bed-rest studies, 
			and flash-blindness studies. Herbert Gerstner,2 [The Committee has no 
			documents at this time indicating that Dr. Gerstner engaged in human 
			experimentation in Germany.] a principal investigator in TBI 
			experiments at the SAM, was acting director of the Institute of 
			Physiology at the University of Leipzig; he became a radiobiologist 
			at the SAM. (Attachment 2)
 
 The Air Force Surgeon General and
				SAM officials welcomed the 
			Paperclip scientists. In March 1951, the school’s Commandant,
				O.O. 
			Benson Jr., wrote to the Surgeon General to seek more
			first-class scientists and highly qualified technologists from 
			Germany. The first group of Paperclip personnel contained a number 
			of scientists that have proved to be of real value to the Air Force. 
			The weaker and less gifted ones have been culled to a considerable 
			extent. The second group reporting here in 1949 were, in general, 
			less competent than the original paperclip personnel, and culling 
			process will again be in order. (Attachment 3)
 
				General Benson’s adjutant solicited resumes from a 
				Paperclip 
			prospect list, including a number of radiation biology and physics 
			specialists. The qualifications of a few scientists were said to be 
			known, so curricula vitae were waived. The adjutant wrote, also in 
			March 1951:
 
					
					"In order to systematically benefit from this program 
			this headquarters believes that the employment of competent 
			personnel who fit into our research program is a most important 
			consideration."  
					(Attachment 4)  
				The Head-Hunting Competition with the Soviet Union
 
 Official U.S. government policy was to avoid recruitment of "ardent 
			Nazis." Many of the Paperclip scientists were members of Nazi 
			organizations of one sort of another. The documentary record 
			indicates, however, that many claimed inactive status or membership 
			that was a formality, according to files in the National Archives.
 
 The director of the Joint Intelligence Objectives Agency, Navy 
				Captain Bosquet N. Wev, bluntly put the case for recruitment in a 
			April 27,1948 memo to the Pentagon’s Director of Intelligence:
 
					
					"Security investigations conducted by the military have disclosed 
			the fact that the majority of German scientists were members of 
			either the Nazi Party or one or more of its affiliates. These 
			investigations disclose further that with a very few exceptions, 
			such membership was due to exigencies which influenced the lives of 
			every citizen of Germany at that time."  
				Wev was critical of 
			over-scrupulous investigations by the Department of Justice 
				and other agencies as 
 
				3 
				reflecting security concerns no longer relevant with the defeat of 
			Germany, and "biased considerations" about the nature of his 
			recruits’ fascist allegiances. (Attachment 5)
 
 The possibility of scientists being won to the Soviet side in the 
			Cold War was, according to Captain Wev, the highest consideration. 
			In a March 1948 letter to the State Department, Wev assessed the 
			prevailing view in the government:
 
					
					"[R]esponsible officials ... have 
			expressed opinions to the effect that, in so far as German 
			scientists are concerned, Nazism no longer should be a serious 
			consideration from a viewpoint of national security when the far 
			greater threat of Communism is now jeopardizing the entire world. I 
			strongly concur in this opinion and consider it a most sound and 
			practical view, which must certainly be taken if we are to face the 
			situation confronting us with even an iota of realism. To continue 
			to treat Nazi affiliations as significant considerations has been 
			aptly phrased as 'beating a dead Nazi horse.’" 
					 
					(Attachment 6)  
				In his April 27,1948 report to his superiors, he again cited the 
			Soviet threat:  
					
					In light of the situation existing in Europe today, it is 
			conceivable that continued delay and opposition to the immigration 
			of these scientists could result in their eventually falling into 
			the hands of the Russians who would then gain the valuable 
			information and ability possessed by these men. Such an eventuality 
			could have a most serious and adverse affect on the national 
			security of the United States.  
					(Attachment 5)   
				Hubertus Strughold and the SAM 
 Perhaps the most prominent of the 
				Paperclip physicians was Hubertus Strughold, called "the father of space medicine" and for whom the
				Aeromedical Library at the USAF School of Aerospace Medicine was 
			named in 1977. During the war, he was director of the Luftwaffe’s aeromedical institute; a 
				Strughold staff member was acquitted at 
			Nuremberg on the grounds that the physician’s Dachau laboratory was 
			not the site of nefarious experiments.
 
 Strughold had a long career at the 
				SAM, including the recruitment of 
			other Paperclip scientists in Germany. His background was the 
			subject of public controversy in the United States. He denied 
			involvement with Nazi experiments and told reporters in this country 
			that his life had been in danger from the Nazis. A citizen for 30 
			years before his death in 1986, his many honors included an 
			Americanism Award from the Daughters of the American Revolution.
 
 
				4 
				An April 1947 intelligence report on 
				Strughold stated:
 
					
					"[H]is 
			successful career under Hitler would seem to indicate that he must 
			be in full accord with Nazism."  
					(Attachment 7)  
				However, Strughold’s 
			colleagues in Germany and those with whom he had worked briefly in 
			the United States on fellowships described him as politically 
			indifferent or anti-Nazi. 
 In his application to reside in this country, he declared:
 
					
					Further, the United States is the only country of liberty which is 
			able to maintain this liberty and the thousand-year-old culture and 
			western civilization, and it is my intention to support the United 
			States in this task, which is in danger now, with all my scientific 
			abilities and experience.  
					(Attachment 8) 
				In a 1952 civil service form, Strughold was asked if he had ever 
			been a member of a fascist organization. His answer: "Not in my 
			opinion." His references therein included the Surgeon General of the 
			Air Force, the director of research at the Lovelace Foundation in 
			New Mexico, and a colleague from the Mayo Clinic. (Attachment 9)
				
 In September 1948, Strughold was granted a security certificate from 
			the Joint Intelligence Objectives Agency director, Captain Wev, who 
			in the previous March had written to the Department of State 
			protesting the difficulty of completing immigration procedures for 
				Paperclip recruits.
 
 
				Follow-up Research
 
 The staff believes this trail should be followed with more research 
			before conclusions can be drawn about the Paperclip scientists and 
			human radiation experiments. That the standard for immigration was 
			"not an ardent Nazi" is troubling; in Strughold’s case, 
			investigators had specifically questioned his credentials for "denazification."
 
 It is possible that still-classified intelligence documents could 
			shed further light on these connections. Staff is attempting to 
			identify sites that may continue to hold this material. The 
			Department of Defense has supplied a number of documents and the 
				Central Intelligence Agency has been asked to search its files. 
			Staff has been sifting declassified files at the National Archives 
			and plans to inspect further classified files on this subject.
 
 
				5 
   
			Paperclip
 from
			
			YouThink Website
 
 With WWII over, the energies of the United Sates and the Soviet 
			Union were redirected into the cold war. But Germany was far from 
			forgotten. In 1946, as US military was hunting down Nazi war 
			criminals, a special intelligence office called the Joint 
			Intelligence Objectives Agency (JIOA) instigated a plan 
			to recruit German scientists into American research programs. These 
			intellectual resources were valuable to the States- and securing 
			them meant that the Soviets could not.
 
 Operation Paper Clip was born - a code name said to have originated 
			because an immigration form (holding the unspoken promise of 
			problem-free naturalization) was attached to the papers of each 
			scientific recruit. Under the auspices of this and similar projects 
			that succeeded it, lasting until the early 1970’s, at least 1600 
			scientists and their families were quietly brought to the USA and 
			given citizenship.
 
 American government policy stated that ‘ardent Nazis’ and war 
			criminals were not allowed to enter the country, and the project 
			was, not surprisingly, the source of some controversy. Conveniently 
			- according to files in the National Archives - most of the Paper 
			Clip scientists had been affiliated to Nazi organizations as a mere 
			formality, and were politically inactive.
 
 In a letter to the State Department in April 1948, the director of 
			JIOA, Captain Bosquet N. Wev, outlined the prevailing view of 
			officialdom:
 
				
				‘In so far as German scientists are 
				concerned, Nazism no longer should be a serious consideration 
				from a viewpoint of national security when the far greater 
				threat of Communism is now jeopardizing the entire world.' 
			Paper Clip was considered a resounding 
			success. The recruits were made welcome at number of military 
			research sites, including the Air Force’s School of Aviation 
			Medicine (SAM), at Brooks Air Force Base, Texas, where 
			radiation experiments were conducted.
 According to the government’s own investigative body, the Advisory 
			Committee on Human Radiation Experiments:
 
				
				‘Experiments at SAM included 
				total-body irradiation, space-medicine and bed-rest studies, and 
				flash blindness studies… in connection with atomic weapons tests 
				and data gathering for total-body irradiation studies conducted 
				in Houston.’ 
			Hubertus Strughold, who had a 
			laboratory at Dachau, began his US career at SAM, and is now known 
			as ‘the father of space medicine’. His chief subordinates at 
			Dachau are widely believed to have been directly involved in 
			‘aviation medicine’ experiments - inhumanely conducted studies of 
			high-altitude exposure, resistance to the cold oxygen deprivation 
			and the like - giving rise to repeated allegations that these 
			medical atrocities were sanctioned by Strughold.
 Many Nazi war criminals managed to avoid prosecution for their 
			crimes, but some were successfully tried at Nuremberg for 
			experiments related to aviation research. The results of such 
			experiments would be extremely useful in the protection of air 
			crewmen.
 
 In March 1951, General O.O. Benson Jr., the Commandant at 
			SAM, wrote to the Surgeon General requesting another shipment of 
			‘first-class scientists and highly qualified technologists from 
			Germany,’ since ‘the first group of Paper Clip personnel contained a 
			number of scientists that have proved to be a real value to the Air 
			Force’.
 
 The scientific community was not the only faction to benefit form 
			the ‘brain drain’ at the close of WWII. Hitler’s master spy 
			Reinhard Gehlen became an important part of America’s 
			intelligence community and recruited others for a small overseas 
			espionage group that helped nurse the CIA into existence. Although 
			Gehlen promised not to recruit anyone who had been involved with the 
			SS or the Gestapo, according to experts Jonathan Vankin and
			John Whalen,
 
				
				‘he immediately broke his official 
				word, hiring at least six SS and Sicherheitdienst veterans. And 
				America’s intelligence elite looked the other way. Two of 
				Gehlen’s notorious post-war signings were Dr Franz Alfred Six 
				and Emil Augsburg, SS intelligence veterans involved in 
				the mass extermination of Jews. They were both fugitive war 
				criminals.’ 
			The US Army’s Counter Intelligence 
			Corps later arrested Six. They caught up with Augsburg too - and 
			hired him. Klaus Barbie, the Butcher of Lyon, also 
			assisted Gehlen for a while in his espionage work for the USA, and 
			even spent some time living there. As Vankin and Whalen note, in an 
			atmosphere of cold war paranoia US officials ‘found expedient soul 
			mates in Nazi scientists and SS officers they recruited. After all, 
			Nazi Germany’s fascists were vehemently opposed to communism, too.’
 
 Unit 731
 
 On 17 June 1925, still reeling from a senseless war that had 
			decimated a generation, most of the earth’s most powerful countries 
			decided they no longer wanted to live in a world of madmen. They 
			signed the Geneva Protocol, outlawing biological and chemical 
			warfare.
 
 The two most conspicuous abstentions were the ever-independent 
			United States and imperial Japan. Japan, in fact, was so impressed 
			by the fact that chemical and biological warfare was considered 
			dangerous enough to ban that it immediately stepped up its research.
 
 The guiding force behind the Japanese effort was a young doctor 
			named Shiro Ishii. Ishii had graduated from the Department of 
			Medicine at Kyoto University in 1920 and gone straight into the 
			Japanese Imperial Army. In the late 1920s he was sent to Europe and 
			the United Sates for two years to study the state of Western 
			biological research. Soon after his return Japan invaded and 
			conquered Manchuria (in what is now China). Ishii and his team had a 
			literal theatre of operations.
 
 In 1936 Emperor Hirohito’s seal was affixed to a document that 
			established Ishii’s Manchuria-based ‘Epidemic Prevention and 
			Water Purification Department of the Kuantung Army ’ (changed to 
			Unit 731 in 1941). The name was a masterpiece of hubris. In fact, 
			the extremely well funded ‘department’ specialized in 
			epidemic-causing toxins like anthrax, cholera, tetanus, botulism, 
			meningitis, tuberculosis and bubonic plague.
   
			A constant supply of test victims was 
			provided courtesy of the occupying Japanese Army. At first they were 
			mostly Chinese and Russian, but once WWII began these were joined 
			with specimens labeled ‘American’, ‘British’, and ‘Australian’. But 
			the staff at Unit 731 had their own special name for the men, women 
			and children they vivisected, almost invariably without anesthetic. 
			They called them 'marutas' : logs.
 The horrors of Unit 731 were unimaginable. Apart from the 
			physical torture suffered by captives before they were killed, there 
			were countless instances of emotional and mental cruelty. In one 
			case, a Japanese doctor vivisected an un-anaesthetized pregnant 
			woman whom he himself had impregnated.
 
 One Unit 731 staffer recently tried to justify his actions:
 
				
				“Of course there were experiments on 
				children. But probably their fathers were spies.” 
			The extreme de-humanization existed 
			outside the army as well. Civilian Japanese doctors would regularly 
			practice surgery techniques on healthy prisoners of war. In one 
			case, eight American servicemen were killed in one day on the 
			operating table at the anatomy department of Kyushu University. They 
			were taken apart bit by bit: first a lung, then a bit of liver, then 
			part of a brain; until finally they died.
 Ishii’s primary interest was not surgery but large-scale biological 
			warfare. He was developing and testing diseases on his 'marutas' 
			with the goal of delivering a fatal does to the enemy whilst 
			learning to treat it in his own men. Throughout the war, Ishii 
			had disease-infected animals (usually fleas) dropped on Chinese 
			towns, where there were several outbreaks of bubonic plague as a 
			result.
 
 His plans extended to the United States. In December 1944, 200 
			balloon bombs were sent using prevailing air currents from Japan to 
			the Western United States, killing seven people in Montana and 
			Oregon. It is likely these balloons were testing the route for 
			bacterial bombs.
 
 As the war was drawing to a close, Ishii had one last bit of 
			insanity up his sleeve. Operation Cherry Blossoms at Night 
			would send plague-laden suicide bombers to San Diego, where the 
			plague would be released and the entire Western seaboard infected. 
			The date of the attack was scheduled for 22 September 1945.
 
 The war in the Pacific ended in August 1945. The cover-up began 
			almost immediately. Ishii was declared dead and a mock funeral was 
			held in his home town. Although he and his staff had destroyed some 
			of the evidence against them before the end of the war, they had 
			plenty of information left to barter. Under the advice of scientists 
			from Fort Detrick, Maryland (the US Army’s own bacterial and 
			chemical research unit), General Douglas MacArthur radioed 
			Washington, recommending that Unit 731 scientists be granted 
			immunity in exchange for their data.
 
 The reply from the committee for the Far East was:
 
				
				“The value of Japanese BW 
				[Biological Warfare] data is of such importance to national 
				security as to far outweigh the value accruing from war crime 
				prosecution.”  
			To its credit, the State Department was 
			against the plan, if only because it might later embarrass the 
			United Sates.
 Not a single member of Unit 731 was prosecuted for war crimes 
			by the United States. The only ones to be prosecuted were twelve who 
			were caught by the Soviets in China: their well-documented trial in 
			1949 was suppressed by the United Sates and regarded as Soviet 
			propaganda.
 
 In spite of articles in 1946 in both the New York Times and 
			the Pacific Stars and Stripes (the official newspaper of the 
			US Army) the government refused to admit that Americans had been the 
			victims of Unit 731, let alone that Ishii was cooperating with the 
			United States.
 
 There were rumors throughout the 1950s that not only had Ishii 
			lectured at Fort Detrick, he had also gone to Korea to help the 
			American war effort. There was certainly some familiar-looking 
			evidence. According to Jonathan Vankin and John Whalen:
 
				
				“On an April night in 1952 an 
				American F-82 fighter was spotted flying over a Chinese village 
				near the Inner Mongolian border. With the break of day, 
				residents were greeted by an infestation of more than seven 
				hundred voles. Of the voles who survived both the night cold and 
				ravaging cats, many ‘were sluggish or had fractured legs’. A 
				test on one dead vole showed it was infected with the plague.” 
			The US government did its best to kill 
			the rumors. In the 1950s, it even resorted to charges of treason 
			against some American civilians who had dared to imply that the 
			government might be using technology originating from Unit 731. The 
			charges were thrown out for lack of evidence.
 The cover-up continues. In 1987, US and British veterans of the 
			Manchuria campaign were told there was ‘no evidence’ for claims that 
			Unit 731 experimented on them. And as recently as 1989, a British 
			book was published in the United Sates minus one chapter freely 
			available in the British, Canadian, Australian and New Zealand 
			editions. The chapter was called ‘The Korean War’.
 
 What of the men of Unit 731? Ishii died of throat cancer at the age 
			of 67 in 1959. Others went on to exalted positions in post-war 
			Japan: Governor of Tokyo, president of the Japanese Medical 
			Association and head of the Japanese Olympic Committee. The leader 
			of the team in charge of inflicting frostbite and vivisecting went 
			on to a lucrative career in the frozen fish industry.
 
 In 1975, the United Sates finally signed the Geneva Protocol.
 
 
 Prison Tests
 
 Prisons have long been a popular testing ground in America. Between 
			1963 and 1973 Dr Heller, an award winning medical scientist, 
			ran a series of experiments on inmates at the Oregon State Prison in 
			order to assess the effect of radiation on sperm production. Another 
			test involving radiation and reproduction was conducted in 
			Washington sate.
   
			Prisoners in Pennsylvania were used to 
			test the effects of radiation on human skin. Inmates in Illinois 
			drank water laced with radium. Prisoners in Utah had their blood 
			removed, irradiated and re-injected. And the tests were not confined 
			to radiation. Just on example: starting in 1944, hundreds of 
			prisoners at Illinois Statesville Prison were given malaria in a 
			project designed to develop a prevention or cure for the disease 
			that was disabling Allied forces in the Pacific.
 According to the government’s own report:
 
				
				“It is difficult to overemphasize 
				just how common the practice [of experimenting on prisoners] 
				became in the United States during the post-war years. 
				Researchers employed prisoners as subjects in a multitude of 
				experiments that ranged in purpose from a desire to understand 
				the cause of cancer to a need to test the effects of a new 
				cosmetic. After the Food and Drug Administration’s restructuring 
				of drug-testing regulations in 1962 prisoners became almost the 
				exclusive subjects in non-federally funded Phase-1 
				pharmaceutical trials designed to test the toxicity of new 
				drugs. By 1972, FDA officials estimated that more than 90% of 
				all investigational drugs were first tested on prisoners.” 
			In at least one case, Upjohn and 
			Parke-Davis built and maintained a large Phase-1 testing facility on 
			the grounds of the State Prison of Southern Michigan.
 Prison testing has more or less been abandoned since the late 1970s, 
			not so much for humanitarian reasons but because the tests were 
			coming under too much scrutiny. And it was becoming easier to employ 
			two other sources of human experimental material: students and the 
			poor.
 
 
 The poor
 
 The poor have a history of being subjected to government-run 
			experiments. Amongst the most infamous was the Tuskegee Study of 
			the early 1930s, in which 412 African-American sharecroppers 
			suffering from syphilis were identified by the US Public Health 
			Service but were not informed of their condition. For forty years – 
			even after penicillin was discovered to treat syphilis – US PHS 
			doctors observed the effects of the disease taking its course, from 
			blindness and paralysis to dementia and death.
 
 Not that treatment was any safer. Woe betide anyone who checked into 
			a research hospital in the middle of the century. At various 
			institutions across the United Sates, Canada and the United Kingdom, 
			patients were injected with plutonium without their knowledge, given 
			radioactive ‘cocktails’ or subjected to full body radiation. In one 
			particularly appalling test, radioactive sodium was injected 
			directly into the placentas of 270 pregnant women at Hammersmith 
			Hospital in England. The adverse results of these experiments varied 
			from amputation to birth defects to death.
 
 
 Radiation Testing
 
 Early in 1963 the Atomic Energy Commission held a conference 
			in Fort Collins, Colorado, for scientists studying the effects of 
			radiation on reproduction. It was the height of the cold war and 
			there were questions that needed to be answered. Questions like the 
			one asked by scientists at an AEC meeting in Washington in 1955:
 
				
				“How many bombs can we detonate 
				without producing a race of monsters?”  
			And questions like the one posed in 1949 
			by an Air Force colonel who enquired how safe nuclear-powered planes 
			would be for his airmen’s ‘family jewels’. NASA wanted to know about 
			the effects of solar radiation on astronauts. And the CIA wanted to 
			know about everything.
 Dr Carl G. Heller recalled what happened:
 
				
				“A given group at Fort Collins was 
				working on mice and another group was working on bulls, and than 
				they extrapolated the data from bulls and mice to man. I 
				commented one day to Dr [Paul] Henshaw, who was then… 
				with the AEC, that if they were so interested in [what would 
				happen to] man, why were they fussing around with mice and 
				beagle dogs and canaries and so on? If they wanted to know about 
				man, why not work on man?” 
			In October 1995, the US government’s 
			Advisory Committee on Human Radiation Experiments published its 
			final report. The committee had been assembled by President 
			Clinton after dogged investigative journalist Albuquerque 
			Tribune reporter Eileen Welsome uncovered evidence of 
			government-sponsored radiation tests on civilians.
 Whilst ground-breaking and laudable, the committee’s mandate was 
			limited to government-funded tests between 1944 and 1974. Another 
			problem was that it relied on self-reporting from various government 
			agencies. The CIA, for example, claim they did only one tiny, 
			innocuous test whereas the Department of Energy admits to 435 
			studies involving 16,000 subjects. Regardless, the range of 
			admitted tests was astounding.
 
 Given that much of this radiation testing was specifically intended 
			to benefit the military, the average soldier did not fare much 
			better than his civilian counter part. Between 1946 and 1963 over 
			200,00 GIs were ordered to watch nuclear bomb tests either in the 
			Pacific or in Nevada. One blast alone in the Marshall Islands was 
			more than 1000 times the size of the Hiroshima bomb.
 
 
 Sunshine
 
 Even in death, citizens are not immune from government testing. 
			Project Sunshine, which started in 1955, was an international 
			body-snatching program that secretly removed body parts from over 
			9000 corpses at 17 sites around the world and sent them to US 
			laboratories for fallout resting. It was described by one sensitive 
			American scientist as “a delicate problem of public relations, 
			obviously”
 
 Prisoners, rank-and-file military, the poor, pregnant women, the 
			dead… Who had the government scientists left out (apart from white, 
			middle-class males, of course)? How about children…
 
 
 Tests on Children
 
 Not surprisingly, scientists didn’t run tests on their own children; 
			they ran them on children in institutions and in reform schools. 
			During the 1950s and 60s, Willowbrook State School in New York, an 
			institution for the severely mentally retarded, was the site of 
			hepatitis testing. Each newly arrived child was systematically 
			infected. The rationale was that these places offered regulated 
			environments that were perfect for replicating lab conditions. 
			Oddly, even though private boarding schools also offered regulated 
			environments, no one ever ran experiments there.
 
 The government’s human radiation committee looked at 21 cases of 
			experimentation on children involving over 800 subjects, a number 
			they themselves admit I just small proportion of what went on. One 
			of the cases they concentrated on was dietary research conducted by 
			the Massachusetts Institute of Technology and the staff of Walter E. 
			Fernald School. A residential institute for boys.
 
 Former residents, some of whom ended up there simply because their 
			families didn’t want them any more, describe the school as being 
			dirty and brutal. In 1946, researchers set up a ‘science club’ at 
			the school, enticing boys to join with such perks as a quart of milk 
			a day and the occasional chance to leave the building.
 
 In return, the boys were to eat a special ‘rich’ diet (breakfast 
			food ‘enriched’ with radioactive iron) and to submit to regular 
			blood tests. Letters to the boys’ parents implied that the testing 
			would improve their health. The research, along with a later 
			experiment at the school involving calcium, was funded by the 
			National Institute of Health, the Atomic energy Commission 
			and the Quaker Oaks Company.
 
 The government report ends its section on ‘non-therapeutic’ tests on 
			children with:
 
				
				“Today, fifty years after the 
				Fernald experiments, there are still no federal regulations 
				protecting institutionalized children from unfair treatment in 
				research involving human subjects.” 
			One ex-Fernald boy, Charlie Dyer, 
			who has fathered two daughters with severe birth defects, said 
			recently:  
				
				“Get to the truth fast before the 
				government hides everything and you can’t find nothing out. 
				Because that’s what the government does, putting it in boxes and 
				crates and hiding everything from the public.”
 
			Reparations
 In October 1995, President Clinton promised to “make 
			repartitions to Americans whose lives were damaged or cut short by 
			these [human radiation] experiments” Of course, it is up to the 
			government (or government-appointed private contractors) to decide 
			who has been ‘damaged’. So far, the vast majority of claims have not 
			been approved. And there are almost no follow-up studies for people 
			irradiated without their knowledge; so they are unlikely to even 
			know what it is that is killing them, let alone that they are 
			eligible for compensation.
 
 The case of 4500 Utah and Nevada sheep, grazing downwind of nuclear 
			test sites, which died ‘mysteriously’ in 1953 shows how willingly 
			reparations are handed out. It took 39 years, much of it spent in 
			court, for the government to be forced into paying compensation. The 
			presiding judge, A. Sherman Christensen, made a point of 
			saying that the US government had lied, pressured witnesses and 
			manipulated the processes of the court.
 
 And yes, the tests never ended.
 
 
 Conclusion
 
 Ultimately, nothing is inconceivable. All you have to do is look at
			Nazi Germany, Many machines have been built that have been 
			engines of evil. Institutionalized evil. Pure Evil… You don’t have 
			to look too hard to imagine the horror that governments are capable 
			of. In the end, it’s the power of the individual that will overcome 
			the inherent evil of a monolith like a government run amuck. A 
			little healthy paranoia is good, I suppose.
     |